The Prodigal Witch Part XV: Stephen Dollins


Stephen Dollins left Satanism for Christ in 1978, becoming a preacher and a crusader against the occult, but it wasn’t until the late ’90s that he gained prominence as a powerful enemy of Harry Potter and the Tooth Fairy.

The following comes from a talk Dollins gave to The Prophecy Club in 1998 or ’99. I must say, his killer mullet-and-tie combo makes him one of the most striking PC speakers in recent memory.

Dollins was born in the late ’50s to a policeman and a nurse, who for some reason put him up for adoption in his infancy. He was adopted by a Christian couple in Oklahoma. His adoptive father was a professor of psychiatry and head of education at Northwestern Oklahoma State University. This would probably be the late Dr. Joe Dollins.
Dollins believes there may been generational witchcraft in his family (he doesn’t specify which one, the biological or adoptive) because as a child he could “make bad things happen to other kids”, Carrie-style. As we have seen with many of the witches and occultists in this series (for instance, Johanna Michaelsen), some fundamentalist Christians believe that any form of occult practice can imbue a person with supernatural powers of a demonic nature, and that these powers can be passed on to descendants like a curse.

Dollins’s troubles with the Devil began in 1969, with an innocent high school assignment on comparative religion. He decided to write his paper on the inefficacy of witchcraft. This led him to a young hippie couple, Kenny and Christie, who not only introduced him to a wide range of illicit substances, but gave him his entré into Satanism. They said a group of their friends would tell him all about the powers of witchcraft if he attended one of their meetings, which were of course top-secret and invitation-only. “When they call, be ready to go,” the hippies warned.
One month later, a coven priestess called Alexandria phoned Stephen just before midnight. He found some pretext to slip out of his house, and was conveyed to a private home in another neighbourhood (this was presumably in or near Alva, Oklahoma, where the university is located). The house had been converted into a ritual space. Nude women were singing around a circle-in-a-pentagram on the floor. The air was already charged with spirits by the time Stephen arrived, so he was instructed to sit in the centre of the circle for his own protection.
The witches obligingly answered all of his questions about hexes, spells, and charms. If they were weirded out by some strange kid doing his homework assignment during one of their rituals, no one said so. In fact, they took a liking to him because of his “inborn powers”, and invited him to another meeting.

This second meeting was held in a ritzier neighbourhood, in a house decorated with an inverted cross and paintings of Hell. Dollins was surprised to find that one of his old biology teachers was the high priest. He was even more surprised to learn that the Satanic witches wanted to recruit him. “We’ve been watching you very carefully,” the biology teacher told him. They tried to entice him into joining their grotto, offering up buffets of coke, mescaline, heroin, and women on demand. But their talk of human sacrifice ultimately scared Stephen away.

In September 1970, Dr. Joe Dollins died. Stephen says he was struck by a hit-and-run driver while riding his bike.
This tragedy drove Stephen straight into the arms of Satan. He wanted nothing to do with a God that would allow his father to die such a cruel, untimely death. He renounced Christianity and filled out an application to join the Church of Satan, formed just three years earlier in California.

He somehow ended up in Clarksville, Texas (the one the Monkees didn’t sing about). He established himself as a high priest in the Church of Satan there, summoning demons to do awful things to people who annoyed him.
He once tried to hex an elderly Christian women by summoning Astaroth. The demon appeared to him in the form of his worst childhood fear: The Wolfman peeking out of an orange cloud. And it was not happy. “Don’t you ever send me after a Christian again!”, Astaroth-Wolfman bellowed.

This sort of incident is repeated again and again by former witches; their demonic powers prove worthless against Christians, before whom even the most powerful minions of hell quiver. You can send demons against anyone, even heads of state, but woe betide you if you send a demon to a pepperpot with a Bible.
These incidents also indicate that demons are not unionized and have to make their own labour complaints.

                  Picture not related

Dollins seems a bit confused about which Satanic organization he joined. At first he calls it the Church of Satan, but later in his talk he identifies it as the Brotherhood, the same nationwide cult to which Mike Warnke supposedly belonged in the mid-’60s. The “denomination” he describes is certainly not the Church of Satan. He mentions that his former co-religionists believe Satan will triumph at Armageddon, and Church of Satan members believe in neither Armageddon nor a literal Satan.

Dollins doesn’t give the size of his Satanic network (perhaps he learned a lesson from the Warnke affair), but he does hint at a massive Satanic conspiracy of the sort John Todd described. He claims the police and sheriff’s departments of a certain town in Texas were in the pockets of local Satanists, and tells us that one Brotherhood member of his acquaintance took part in animal sacrifice and child abduction (he doesn’t tell us if he reported this guy to the proper authorities or not, but given later events and Mike Warnke’s example, we can safely assume he did not).

In Topeka, Kansas, Stephen wed his high priestess. This is where the powers of Hell abandoned him (apparently, even Satan doesn’t like Kansas). He ended up broke and suicidally depressed. Then he remembered reading Mike Warnke’s memoir, The Satan Seller. The book had been given to him by the same Brotherhood member who sacrificed animals, after he was saved by a Christian ministry called Crisis Answers.
Thanks to Warnke’s book and his child-kidnapping buddy, Dollins realized he could leave the Brotherhood.
Remember, this talk was given in the late ’90s, six or seven years after Warnke’s lies were exposed by Cornerstone magazine. Tying his story to Warnke’s was a serious tactical mistake on Dollins’s part. More than anything else, this indicates that his story is 100% fictional. Sure, maybe he met some hippies in Oklahoma who smoked hash and dabbled in witchcraft, but he didn’t become a high priest of the Brotherhood. There is no Brotherhood. It was Warnke’s invention.

Anyway, Dollins phoned up his animal-sacrificing friend and learned, to his amazement, that a group of Christians had been praying for his salvation for the past seven years. The friend arranged for him to meet with two pastors who love-bombed the hell out of him, literally. He was saved on Groundhog Day, 1978.
This part of the story jives perfectly with the other remarkable conversions we’ve seen in this series. No former witch or reformed Satanist is content to say, “I worshiped the Devil for x number of years, then I got bored with it and became a Christian.”

Though Mike Warnke faced the threat of assassination after leaving the Brotherhood, Dollins mentions no retaliatory measures. That’s to his credit. In the stories of John Todd, Doc Marquis, “Elaine” (Edna Moses), and Warnke, it’s very hard to believe that an enormous cult with the powers of Hell at its beck and call can’t manage to bump off a few unarmed guys who regularly appear in public without so much as a single bodyguard. It makes for some compelling Christian testimony, but in the realism department it gets a big, fat zero.

Dollins has dedicated his Christian life to warning against the hazards of the occult. Now you would think by “occult”, I mean summoning Wolfman demons and putting curses on old women and whatnot, right? Well, Dollins doesn’t get quite that far. Just like the anti-occult crusaders and former witches of the ’70s and ’80s, he decided that the best way to keep kids out of Satanism is to make sure they aren’t exposed to any occult influences at a tender age. Don’t let your kids read the Harry Potter books. Don’t hang dreamcatchers over babies’ cribs; Native spirituality is not Christian, therefore it is demon-inspired. Don’t tell your child about the Tooth Fairy.

Wait, what? The Tooth Fairy?

Yes, the Tooth Fairy. Dollins asks his audience, in all seriousness, “How many know fairies are demons?”, then tells us, “When you talk to your child about the Tooth Fairy, you’re actually telling them about a demon.” *

I thought we were giving kids a convenient explanation for why we take their teeth and replace them with small amounts of money.

Dollins also warns against Pokemon (because it encourages children to become “masters”, seems to involve cute little demons with occult powers, and may cause seizures), Sarah Coventry jewelry (“occult” designs), and role-playing games. “The more you get into the fantasy world, the more it seems real, and all of a sudden now you don’t know what’s real and what’s not,” he says without the faintest trace of irony.

Dollins actually wrote an entire book about the dangers of Harry Potter, Under the Spell of Harry Potter (Global Distributing Services, 2002). It’s not the only one, of course, but it does seem to contain the least amount of integrity. In the intro, Dollins quotes two young Harry Potter fans as “anonymous sources”, implying that these were children he personally interviewed. In reality, the quotes came directly from two San Francisco Chronicle articles, as pointed out by the pro-Potter website Dollins Debunked.

To sum it all up, there isn’t much to say about Mr. Dollins. He wasn’t even creative enough to come up with his own Satanic cult mythos; he just recycled discredited stuff from the ’70s, threw in some weirdness about demonic fairies, and jumped on the anti-Harry Potter bandwagon with numerous other fundamentalists. He followed a script, laid down by Doreen Irvine in the early ’70s, that is now extremely familiar:

– A Dickensian childhood full of abuse, exploitation, and deprivation (Dollins skipped this step, as his adoptive parents were perfectly nice Christians).
– An early introduction to Jesus that would pave the way for salvation later in life
– An absence of time markers (the only two dates Dollins provides are the year of his introduction to devil worship and the date of his conversion to Christianity)
– Lack of detail about the beliefs of Satanists (scripture, philosophy, etc.), but extraneous detail about the practices of Satanists (sacrifice, crime, etc.). Dollins mentions absolutely no scripture at all, not even the fictional tome called The Great Mother that Warnke’s Brotherhood used.
– Helplessness. Rather than being led into Satanic evil through his/her bad choices, the protagonist is usually a naive and vulnerable innocent victimized, lured, or coerced into sin by more worldly people. Once ensnared, escape is impossible. Teenage Dollins was heavily dosed with drugs before being enticed into Satanism. He was just a nice, normal kid trying to finish a school assignment.
– Supernatural events and paranormal abilities are common. Demons and angels materialize, Satanists use death curses against their enemies, and sometimes Satan himself makes an appearance. Dollins caught the attention of Satanists because he possessed inherited supernatural powers, and later trained himself to physically summon demons.
– A remarkable conversion experience
– Complete redemption and forgiveness through Christ
– Expert advice on the occult. After sharing his/her testimony, the ex-witch or former Satanist gives us pointers on how to avoid occultism, prevent children from becoming involved in it, and/or how to expunge it from our communities. There are typically warnings about Ouija boards, Halloween, and occult literature. Or in Dollins’s case, fictional boy wizards and the freaking Tooth Fairy.

Please note that Dollins did not mention telling your kids about Tom Noonan. So feel free to do that.

33 thoughts on “The Prodigal Witch Part XV: Stephen Dollins

Add yours

  1. And once again we find that the story goes that the 'Satanists' BEGAN their sales pitch talking about human sacrifice. In reality any organisation engaging in such behaviour would only reveal the fact to a recruit after some time in the cult, when they were sure that the person would not just go straight to the police; yet like Audrey Harper Dollins has that at the beginning. Harper could at least use the excuse that she was a homeless drug-addicted hooker, Dollins was supposedly a thoroughly respectable lad at the time. It makes no sense, it is in fact impossible.Incidentally, I am an Evangelical pastor who has read most of the Harry Potter books, and I think they are just harmless fiction that is actually compatible with Christianity, and contain Christian themes (the author is a member of the Church of Scotland). Writing books involving fictional magic has no necessary connection with any religious group at all. Philip Pullman, author of 'The Golden Compass' is an ardent atheist, and he wrote books full of magic. The message of a book is rarely in the trappings, but in the plot.

  2. I agree that any cult practicing human sacrifice (if there are any at the moment) would probably not reveal their innermost secrets to a non-member, much less a high school kid. And no Satanist would want a square teenager hanging around with a pad and pencil during a private ritual, asking, "Whatcha doin'? What's this? Why are y'all naked?" Fantasy fiction and RPGs are quite harmless. I have some issues with the Narnia books and a few other fantasy/scifi novels (like those of Frank Peretti), but that's a different post…

  3. As a rule secretive sects do not talk about their most sacred rites with outsiders; if they did, then everyone would know about them! That's why we have very little about the ancient Druids and some of the Mystery Religions like Mithraism to go on – they didn't write things down but passed them on by word of mouth. I have read and enjoyed fantasy and Sci Fi for years, with no ill effects, and we're talking Lord of the Rings, Dune, Narnia, a great amount of Asimov and Arthur C. Clark, not to mention all the stuff I read when I was a lad, and film and TV. What's deeply depressing is that there are Christians who abominate Harry Potter as evil who have no trouble at all with Perreti, despite the fact that similar claims could be made about him.

  4. I've read some of Peretti's young adult fiction. Scary stuff. He spends a great of time trying to convince his readers that secular education is the scourge of the planet (which is rather pointless, as many of his readers are probably homeschooled. Maybe he's trying to frighten them away from university).

    1. Secular education is getting more and more bizarre, as governments’ laws become more and more bizarre… We have 5th grade elementary school kids being taught ‘how to have SAFE butt sex!’ Hello?! We have homosexuals adopting innocent defenseless orphans! Hello?! Don’t these children have any rights? We have beastiality legalised in countries like Denmark! At the same time, bible teaching and prayer is being prohibited in schools and public places… I’ve met people who have lost their job, just for wearing a cross!! ‘It’ o.k. darling if you have sex with a dog, but don’t speak about Jesus, or wear a cross…and don’t even think about praying, that’s illegal!!’ I don’t know how long it will take for God to say: ‘ENOUGH IS ENOUGH’, AND THEN, WE’LL ALL BE IN TROUBLE! (Today, when someone talks to God, it’s called prayer… But when God talks back, it’s scizophrenia…).

      1. Please, please, provide us with evidence that bestiality is legal in Denmark.

      2. Yes, sad but true, beastiality is legal in denmark, germany and other nations, where there are ‘animal brothels’, LOL! (look it up on internet)…Sodom and gommorah all over again! (while in 3rd world countries, this sexual perversion, and homosexuality, is Not legal…). Maybe we ‘sophisticated’ ‘christian’ westerners, have something to learn from them! LOL! God help us!

  5. De 18:10 There shall not be found among you any one that maketh his son or his daughter to pass through the fire, or that useth divination, or an observer of times, or an enchanter, or a witch, 11 Or a charmer, or a consulter with familiar spirits, or a wizard, or a necromancer. 12 For all that do these things are an abomination unto the LORD: and because of these abominations the LORD thy God doth drive them out from before thee. 13 Thou shalt be perfect with the LORD thy God. 14 For these nations, which thou shalt possess, hearkened unto observers of times, and unto diviners: but as for thee, the LORD thy God hath not suffered thee so to do. Exodus 22:18 Thou shalt not suffer a witch to live.Curses from Satanists/witches don't just 'bounce right off Christians'. That is hogwash. There must be active spiritual warfare to break the curses in Jesus' Holy Name and also not give in to the onslaughts. Curses are hordes of devils sent upon a soul/souls.

  6. Since I don't know Dollins personally I can't say the accuracy of what he is saying but I can confirm that Christians hold great power in the blood and name of Jesus. I was once trying to do a seance at my birthday party and I couldn't because there was a Christian praying against it. I can also back up his claims about fairies since a girl came to school one day to to teach on Wicca and she shared that fairies were used for their practices. You can bury your head in a hole but the truth is witchcraft is real but Jesus' power is stronger so I serve Him.

  7. I agree with the previous 'anonymous'. I once invoked a third level demon to help me levitate, but I didn't know there was a religious leaflet on my doorstep.The power of that leaflet was so great that I couldn't lift off.

  8. Regarding both blogs (this one and the Alex Jones one): I'm sorry to say this, but you are nothing more than a pro-state troll. Your attitude towards the truth community is sickening. I hope the Powers That Be paid you a lot for your soul.

  9. I apologize if the previous comment seemed too harsh. In truth, your blogs are well written and quite informative, and it was rude to call you a statist troll. I still dislike your blogs (especially the Alex Jones one), but there was no need for me to be rude about it. If the comment offended you, I apologize.

  10. Anonymous – your postings here are hilarious! although I doubt you intended them to be. I have to ask: are you a child? Do your mommy & daddy know that you are posting messages on the websites of grown-ups?You couldn't "do a seance", because no one can, because seances are fantasy BS. The presence or absent of believers from any faith group is totally irrelevant. As for "invoking a third level demon" – you do understand that Dungeons & Dragons is a GAME and not reality, don't you?If you think you can "fight the state" by babbling superstitious nonsense, you're sadly mistaken. That's the problem with most self-professed Truthers – too much self-righteous babble, not enough practical action. Try joining "Food Not Bombs", or something, if you want to make a difference.

    1. HAHAHA…..Just because you haven’t been to a seance, where psychic mediums, or Satanists make spirits/demons materialise, and ask them for favours….doesn’t mean that this doesn’t happen, LOLOL. Look out of the box you live in, and learn to respect, or at least consider other peoples’ verified experiences!!!! Read two awesome internationally best selling books, autobiographies of people who “been there, done that” for DECADES!!! ( from 1)- “OUT OF THE DEVIL’S COULDRON” ,by john Ramirez. 2)- “SPIRIT OF THE RAINFOREST” (forgot the author). Sweet dreams😊

  11. We've been having a lot of fun with those Anon comments on Facebook:- "Oh man I HATE it when Christian propaganda keeps me from having magical demon powers."- I summoned the hordes of hell to clean my bathroom, then some JWs knocked on the door and ruined EVERYTHING. *scrubbing toilet*Etc.

  12. – "Oh man I HATE it when Christian propaganda keeps me from having magical demon powers."ROFL! TOO funny!I had this strange experience awhile ago…I spent some time on a forum that boldy proclaimed itself to be "Occult Forums' dedicated to discussion primarily of the mythical LHP. I was there to address a serious matter, in a serious & scholoarly manner. That thread was not too bad – but elsewhere on that site the questions posed and answerts given were just bizarrely ignorant, superstitious and uneducated. It took me a long time to figure out that most of the denizens had to be CHILDREN – egads! Needless to say, I fled and won't ever go back.

  13. Actually Harry Potter's life mirrors that of satanist Aleister Crowley quite a bit.also the author admits that she got all the characters automatically out of knowhere (aka similar to automatic writing) occultism is satanic and that's it..and anything that deals with supernatural and magic can get kids interested in witchcraft at a young age…even if it take a while before they experiment; it's still planting the seed. Far from harmless…

    1. No it doesn’t. Aleister Crowley was brought up by devout Plymouth Brethren. Harry Potter’s upbringing isn’t religious at all. Aleister Crowley’s youthful pursuits were chess and mountain climbing. Harry Potter plays quidditch, which bears no resemblance to either. Aleister Crowley created his image as a master of “magick” by himself, out of a desire to be special and outrageous. Harry Potter’s identity as a wizard is unexpectedly thrust upon him. I don’t think you know much about Harry Potter OR Aleister Crowley.

  14. ANd yes the Bortherhood is real…you people are ignorant or just trying to keep people in the dark. The satnic brotherhood even has a website for goodness sakes. Wakeup.

  15. And tinky winky is gay. And listening to rock music will send you straight to hell. Come on!! My boys read and watched Harry Potter, Narnia etc. they both play rpg games and they are both fine, well adjusted respectful and God fearing. Get over it!! It's called parenting. I heard all of this crap while growing up. My mother was a church goer, Dad was not. I experienced both and I'm fine ( I think, well who knows and I don't really care). PARENT your children and they will be fine.

  16. You peeps sound slike you dont actaully look anything up or do any research. Do you think the world isnt the same as it was 2000 years ago? Look up Al Aqsa. FOr God's saks. Satan is obviously still the best deciever in the world. This guy knows what hes talkin about.

  17. One problem with Mr. Dollins is, whether his intentions are good, bad, or purely gainsaying for his own lucrative purposes, he tends to take the Lord's name in vain. All throughout his videos. Either by saying it too much, as God's name is not to be thrown around and regarded so lightly, or just outright saying, "Oh my…." .. you know what I mean. Whether this is a bad habit he formed from his alleged involvement with Satanism, or if he forgot to read the The Ten Commandments(which is sarcastic and unlikely), fact is, he does it. Also, even if it is for educational purposes, I don't think one should bring Satanist symbols into a (any) church. In his video, The Occult In Your Living room(, he shows a display of about a hundred different symbols which are projected onto the wall of the particular church he is preaching to, of which he shows the same symbols repeatedly, after previously having explained what he believes they mean. If the adversary were to successfully send one of his minions into a church to post his evil symbols, this would be an abomination towards God, thus, it would be pleasing to the adversary. I'm not trying to debunk him, I'm just saying, let us not be a victim of attitudinized scripture or beliefs. Let each man search out for himself, and gain the discernment on his own accord.

  18. Stephen Dollins is a fraud and plagiarist. Worse, he plagiarized a book that has been proven false for decades. (The two Babylons by Alexander Hislop.

  19. On the 6th of June Thor’s day, I created Mellifluous Anonymous from nothing. Satan is now dead

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Blog at

Up ↑

%d bloggers like this: